| Met. | Imp. | Athlete | School | Conference | Class | Location | Date |
| 5.35 | 17'06.50" | Chris Swanson | Otterbein | Ohio (OAC) | 2005 | Columbus | 01/29/05 |
| 5.22 | 17'01.50" | Nick Pergande | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2006 | Bloomington | 03/12/05 |
| 5.12 | 16'09.50" | Brian DeLoriea | North Central | Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) | 2005 | Bloomington | 03/12/05 |
| 5.12 | 16'09.50" | Matt Novak | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2006 | Bloomington | 03/12/05 |
| 5.02 | 16'05.50" | Kyle Stumpenhorst | North Central | Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) | 2005 | Bloomington | 03/12/05 |
| 5.02 | 16'05.50" | Shannon Bennington | Mount Union | Ohio (OAC) | Bloomington | 03/12/05 | |
| 5.00 | 16'04.75" | Jon Heinz | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2006 | Platteville | 03/05/05 |
| 5.00 | 16'04.75" | Nathan Ball | MIT | NEWMAC | 2005 | Medford | 02/19/05 |
| 4.96 | 16'03.25" | Ryan Schipper | Rose-Hulman | Southern (SCAC) | 2007 | Jacksonville | 02/12/05 |
| 4.92 | 16'01.75" | Derek Zulkoski | Nebraska Wesleyan | Great Plains (GPAC) | 2007 | Bloomington | 03/12/05 |
| 4.83 | 15'10.00" | Zach Johnson | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2007 | Oshkosh | 02/19/05 |
| 4.80 | 15'09.00" | Chris Schmauder | Ohio Northern | Ohio (OAC) | 2006 | Columbus | 01/29/05 |
| 4.80 | 15'09.00" | Matt Schroeder | St. Thomas | Minnesota (MIAC) | 2007 | Ames | 01/28/05 |
| 4.80 | 15'09.00" | Tyler Gutierrez | SUNY Cortland | SUNYAC | 2006 | New York | 02/25/05 |
| 4.75 | 15'07.00" | Lewis Cassellius | Wisconsin-Stout | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2004 | Menomonie | 02/05/05 |
| 4.75 | 15'07.00" | Will Snyder | Southern Maine | Little East | 2005 | Reno | 01/22/05 |
| 4.71 | 15'05.50" | Stephen Robin | Alfred | New York (NYSCTC) | Rochester | 02/26/05 | |
| 4.70 | 15'05.00" | Alex Tapplin | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2007 | Stevens Point | 02/26/05 |
| 4.70 | 15'05.00" | Alex Wise | Macalester | Minnesota (MIAC) | 2007 | Minneapolis | 02/18/05 |
| 4.70 | 15'05.00" | Greg Gause | Puget Sound | Northwest (NWC) | 2006 | Seattle | 01/30/05 |
| 4.70 | 15'05.00" | Jacob Bremer | North Central | Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) | 2005 | Romeoville | 02/19/05 |
| 4.70 | 15'05.00" | Tim Jankowski | Wisconsin-Platteville | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2006 | Platteville | 03/05/05 |
| 4.69 | 15'04.50" | Jake Krueger | Hamline | Minnesota (MIAC) | 2007 | Northfield | 02/26/05 |
| 4.69 | 15'04.50" | Jonathon Todd | Bowdoin | NESCAC | 2005 | Canton | 03/05/05 |
| 4.67 | 15'03.75" | Travis Wagenknecht | Nebraska Wesleyan | Great Plains (GPAC) | 2007 | Lincoln | 02/26/05 |
| 4.65 | 15'03.00" | Andrew Butler | Muskingum | Ohio (OAC) | 2006 | Marietta | 02/04/05 |
| 4.65 | 15'03.00" | Andy Rollins | Lynchburg | Old Dominion (ODAC) | 2006 | Lexington | 12/04/04 |
| 4.65 | 15'03.00" | Conrad Rapp | Allegheny | North Coast (NCAC) | 2008 | Kent | 02/19/05 |
| 4.65 | 15'03.00" | Dayson Tiogangco | Linfield | Northwest (NWC) | 2005 | Seattle | 02/13/05 |
| 4.65 | 15'03.00" | Michael Holland | Muskingum | Ohio (OAC) | 2007 | Kent | 02/19/05 |
| 4.64 | 15'02.75" | Bill Borgman | Wilmington | Ohio (OAC) | 2006 | Columbus | 01/29/05 |
| 4.60 | 15'01.00" | Justin Loda | Christopher Newport | Mid-Continent (MCC) | 2007 | Blacksburg | 03/05/05 |
| 4.57 | 15'00.00" | Chad Eagy | Ohio Northern | Ohio (OAC) | 2007 | Ada | 02/18/05 |
| 4.57 | 15'00.00" | John Rohn | Illinois College | Midwest (MWC) | 2007 | Jacksonville | 03/05/05 |
| 4.57 | 15'00.00" | Jon Blome | Illinois Wesleyan | Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) | 2007 | Jacksonville | 02/12/05 |
| 4.57 | 15'00.00" | Kevin Clark | Elizabethtown | Mid-Atlantic (MAC) | Boston | 02/11/05 | |
| 4.56 | 14'11.50" | Garrett Butler | Johns Hopkins | Centennial (CC) | Landover | 01/22/05 | |
| 4.55 | 14'11.00" | Andrew Soderstrom | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2006 | Stevens Point | 02/26/05 |
| 4.55 | 14'11.00" | Brandon O'Toole | RPI | New York (NYSCTC) | 2007 | Hamilton | 02/13/05 |
| 4.55 | 14'11.00" | Daniel Swan | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2008 | Platteville | 03/05/05 |
| 4.55 | 14'11.00" | Jake Owens | Richard Stockton | New Jersey (NJAC) | 2006 | New York | 02/12/05 |
| 4.55 | 14'11.00" | Kyle Graham | Hamilton | NESCAC | 2006 | Hamilton | 02/13/05 |
| 4.55 | 14'11.00" | Matt Hawn | St. John's (MN) | Minnesota (MIAC) | 2006 | Moorhead | 03/05/05 |
| 4.55 | 14'11.00" | Nathaniel Blazier | Carthage | Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) | 2007 | Romeoville | 02/19/05 |
| 4.55 | 14'11.00" | Rob Friendt | St. Mary's (MN) | Minnesota (MIAC) | 2006 | Moorhead | 03/05/05 |
| 4.54 | 14'10.75" | Andy Smith | Wisconsin-Stout | Wisconsin-Stout | 2006 | Northfield | 02/26/05 |
| 4.53 | 14'10.25" | Jason Petit | Augustana (IL) | Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) | 2007 | Bloomington | 02/26/05 |
| 4.53 | 14'10.25" | Justin Wolfe | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2004 | Menomonie | 02/18/05 |
| 4.53 | 14'10.25" | Michael Bina | North Central | Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) | 2008 | Bloomington | 02/26/05 |
| 4.50 | 14'09.00" | Aaron Mangold | Washington-St. Louis | University (UAA) | 2007 | Marion | 02/05/05 |
| 4.50 | 14'09.00" | Adam Lendowski | Wisconsin-Whitewater | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2005 | Platteville | 01/15/05 |
| 4.50 | 14'09.00" | Conrad Warmbold | Washington-St. Louis | University (UAA) | 2005 | New York | 02/25/05 |
| 4.50 | 14'09.00" | Drew Hood | Gustavus Adolphus | Minnesota (MIAC) | 2008 | Northfield | 02/25/05 |
| 4.50 | 14'09.00" | Jonathon Henkins | Monmouth (IL) | Midwest (MWC) | 2008 | Marion | 02/05/05 |
| 4.50 | 14'09.00" | Matt Hampl | Nebraska Wesleyan | Great Plains (GPAC) | 2005 | Sioux Center | 02/19/05 |
| 4.50 | 14'09.00" | Michael El Kazzaz | Moravian | Mid-Atlantic (MAC) | 2006 | Reno | 01/22/05 |
| 4.50 | 14'09.00" | Ryan West | Rowan | New Jersey (NJAC) | 2006 | New York | 02/25/05 |
| 4.49 | 14'08.75" | Peter Sprecher | Monmouth (IL) | Midwest (MWC) | Whitewater | 02/26/05 | |
| 4.47 | 14'08.00" | Derek Gibbons | Capital | Ohio (OAC) | 2007 | Marietta | 03/05/05 |
| 4.45 | 14'07.25" | Dave Falcinelli | RIT | New York (NYSCTC) | 2007 | Ithaca | 02/12/05 |
| 4.45 | 14'07.25" | Patrick Hegel | St. John's (MN) | Minnesota (MIAC) | 2005 | Collegeville | 02/18/05 |
| 4.42 | 14'06.00" | Anthony Pavia | Lynchburg | Old Dominion (ODAC) | 2008 | Newport News | 02/27/05 |
| 4.42 | 14'06.00" | Brian Hoffman | College of New Jersey | New Jersey (NJAC) | Lawrenceville | 02/06/05 | |
| 4.42 | 14'06.00" | Carl Stuart | Christopher Newport | Mason-Dixon | Newport News | 02/12/05 | |
| 4.42 | 14'06.00" | Chris Zath | Mount Union | Ohio (OAC) | 2007 | Marietta | 02/19/05 |
| 4.42 | 14'06.00" | Jason Langley | RPI | NYSCTC | 2006 | Hanover | 02/05/05 |
| 4.42 | 14'06.00" | Jon Brallier | Franklin & Marshall | Centennial (CC) | 2007 | Selinsgrove | 02/18/05 |
| 4.42 | 14'06.00" | Rob Daniele | Susquehanna | Mid-Atlantic (MAC) | 2006 | Selinsgrove | 01/21/05 |
| 4.42 | 14'06.00" | Rory Maxwell | Eastern Connecticut | Little East | 2007 | Middleton | 01/29/05 |
| 4.42 | 14'06.00" | Scott Decker | Lynchburg | Old Dominion (ODAC) | 2008 | Newport News | 02/27/05 |
| 4.42 | 14'06.00" | Seth LaPierre | Tufts | NESCAC | 2006 | Medford | 02/19/05 |
| 4.41 | 14'05.50" | Aaron Dove | Eastern Mennonite | Old Dominion (ODAC) | 2008 | Landover | 01/22/05 |
| 4.41 | 14'05.50" | Chris Brhel | SUNY Brockport | New York (NYSCTC) | 2007 | Geneva | 02/19/05 |
| 4.41 | 14'05.50" | Josh Smith | Eastern Mennonite | Old Dominion (ODAC) | 2007 | Landover | 01/22/05 |
| 4.40 | 14'05.25" | Dane Justice | Monmouth (IL) | Midwest (MWC) | 2006 | Monmouth | 02/12/05 |
| 4.40 | 14'05.25" | Justin Lenzo | Richard Stockton | New Jersey (NJAC) | 2006 | New York | 02/12/05 |
| 4.40 | 14'05.25" | Patrick Doty | Wisconsin-Stout | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2006 | Platteville | 03/05/05 |
| 4.40 | 14'05.25" | Shean Perry | Oberlin | North Coast (NCAC) | 2006 | Oberlin | 02/25/05 |
| 4.39 | 14'04.75" | Brad Hansen | St. Thomas | Minnesota (MIAC) | 2007 | Northfield | 02/26/05 |
| 4.38 | 14'04.50" | Sverre Sundgaard | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2007 | Oshkosh | 02/19/05 |
| 4.38 | 14'04.50" | Victor Beltran | North Central | Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) | 2008 | Bloomington | 02/26/05 |
| 4.37 | 14'04.00" | Brian Tripp | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2008 | Northfield | 02/12/05 |
| 4.37 | 14'04.00" | Jason Stocker | Wisconsin-Platteville | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2008 | Oshkosh | 02/05/05 |
| 4.37 | 14'04.00" | Mark Dobish | Allegheny | North Coast (NCAC) | 2007 | Granville | 03/05/05 |
| 4.37 | 14'04.00" | Nate Page | St. Thomas | Minnesota (MIAC) | 2005 | Northfield | 02/12/05 |
| 4.37 | 14'04.00" | Nicholas Onesti | Wisconsin-Stout | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2005 | Northfield | 02/12/05 |
| 4.37 | 14'04.00" | Nicholas Rhoades | Heidelberg | Ohio (OAC) | 2006 | Marietta | 03/05/05 |
| 4.37 | 14'04.00" | Nick Neuman | Wisconsin-Stout | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2006 | Northfield | 02/12/05 |
| 4.37 | 14'04.00" | Ryan Petersen | Nebraska Wesleyan | Great Plains (GPAC) | Lincoln | 02/26/05 | |
| 4.37 | 14'04.00" | Steve Johnson | Baldwin-Wallace | Ohio (OAC) | 2007 | Marietta | 03/05/05 |
| 4.35 | 14'03.25" | Brian Eichhorn | Chicago | University (UAA) | 2005 | New York | 02/25/05 |
| 4.35 | 14'03.25" | Noel Durant | Lynchburg | Old Dominion (ODAC) | 2008 | Lexington | 12/04/04 |
| 4.35 | 14'03.25" | Ryan Morey | Bethel (MN) | Minnesota (MIAC) | 2008 | Northfield | 02/25/05 |
| 4.35 | 14'03.25" | Tom George | Nebraska Wesleyan | Great Plains (GPAC) | 2005 | Lincoln | 01/15/05 |
| 4.34 | 14'02.75" | Adam Haggerty | Southern Maine | Little East | 2008 | Gorham | 02/12/05 |
| 4.34 | 14'02.75" | Andrew Fetzner | SUNY Brockport | New York (NYSCTC) | 2005 | Canton | 01/22/05 |
| 4.30 | 14'01.25" | Cory Torkelson | Central (IA) | Iowa (IIAC) | 2006 | Storm Lake | 02/05/05 |
| 4.28 | 14'00.50" | Zach Barniger | Franklin & Marshall | Centennial (CC) | 2007 | Carlisle | 02/27/05 |
| 4.27 | 14'00.00" | Chad Showen | Marietta | Ohio (OAC) | 2005 | Marietta | 02/25/05 |
| 4.27 | 14'00.00" | Darin Wilson | Muskingum | Ohio (OAC) | Westerville | 01/22/05 | |
| 4.27 | 14'00.00" | Donald Hackworth | Penn State-Erie-Behrend | independent | 2005 | Alliance | 02/26/05 |
| 4.27 | 14'00.00" | Eric Nicely | Defiance | Heartland (HCAC) | 2006 | Ada | 02/25/05 |
| 4.27 | 14'00.00" | Joseph Northrup | Bates | NESCAC | 2005 | Medford | 02/19/05 |
| 4.27 | 14'00.00" | Kyle Wilson | Fitchburg State | Masachusetts (MASCAC) | 2007 | Middleton | 01/29/05 |
| 4.27 | 14'00.00" | Nestor Hernandez | MIT | NEWMAC | 2005 | Brunswick | 01/29/05 |
| 4.27 | 14'00.00" | Paul Mason | Otterbein | Ohio (OAC) | 2008 | Granville | 02/19/05 |
| 4.27 | 14'00.00" | Tim McDonald | Illinois Wesleyan | Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) | 2005 | Jacksonville | 02/12/05 |
| 4.26 | 13'11.75" | Jason Legault | RPI | NYSCTC | 2006 | Rochester | 02/26/05 |
| 4.26 | 13'11.75" | Ted Esborn | Johns Hopkins | Centennial (CC) | 2006 | Landover | 01/22/05 |
| 4.25 | 13'11.25" | Adam Polite | USMMA-King's Point | 2006 | New York | 02/12/05 | |
| 4.25 | 13'11.25" | Brandon Carpenter | Linfield | Northwest (NWC) | Seattle | 02/13/05 | |
| 4.25 | 13'11.25" | Brandon Robison | Coe | Iowa (IIAC) | 2005 | Decorah | 02/25/05 |
| 4.25 | 13'11.25" | Joel Ross | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2005 | Stevens Point | 02/26/05 |
| 4.25 | 13'11.25" | Matt Meidl | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2005 | Platteville | 03/05/05 |
| 4.25 | 13'11.25" | Mycola Kamper | Wisconsin-River Falls | Wisconsin (WIAC) | Platteville | 03/05/05 | |
| 4.24 | 13'11.00" | Chae Zeller | St. John's (MN) | Minnesota (MIAC) | Northfield | 02/26/05 | |
| 4.23 | 13'10.50" | Kyle Smith | Hope | Michigan (MIAA) | 2007 | Oshkosh | 02/19/05 |
| 4.23 | 13'10.50" | Timmy Linn | Wheaton (IL) | Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) | 2008 | Bloomington | 02/26/05 |
| 4.23 | 13'10.50" | Wes Jackson | Augustana (IL) | Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) | 2008 | Whitewater | 02/12/05 |
| 4.22 | 13'10.00" | Jacob Peters | Wisconsin-Platteville | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2008 | Oshkosh | 02/05/05 |
| 4.22 | 13'10.00" | Ryan Peterson | Nebraska Wesleyan | Great Plains (GPAC) | Lincoln | 01/29/05 | |
| 4.22 | 13'10.00" | Tony Fontanini | Wisconsin-Platteville | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2008 | Oshkosh | 02/05/05 |
| 4.20 | 13'09.25" | Chris Clausen | USMMA-King's Point | 2008 | New York | 02/25/05 | |
| 4.20 | 13'09.25" | Chris Randolph | Seattle Pacific | Northwest (NWC) | 2006 | Reno | 01/22/05 |
| 4.20 | 13'09.25" | John Thompson | Augustana (IL) | Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) | 2008 | Rock Island | 02/05/05 |
| 4.20 | 13'09.25" | Kevin Probst | SUNY Plattsburgh | SUNYAC | 2006 | New York | 02/25/05 |
| 4.20 | 13'09.25" | Kurt Vandenheuvel | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2007 | Platteville | 03/05/05 |
| 4.20 | 13'09.25" | T. J. Meagher | Kean | New Jersey (NJAC) | New York | 02/25/05 | |
| 4.20 | 13'09.25" | Tyler Ties | Gustavus Adolphus | Minnesota (MIAC) | 2007 | Northfield | 02/25/05 |
| 4.19 | 13'09.00" | Brandon Johnson | Bethel (MN) | Minnesota (MIAC) | 2007 | Eau Claire | 01/21/05 |
| 4.19 | 13'09.00" | Justin Henneman | Tufts | NESCAC | 2007 | Medford | 02/12/05 |
| 4.19 | 13'09.00" | Scott Bauer | Carthage | Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) | 2005 | Kenosha | 02/12/05 |
| 4.19 | 13'09.00" | Tony Marcinek | Wisconsin-La Crosse | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2007 | Menomonie | 01/29/05 |
| 4.16 | 13'07.75" | Demetrius Hlovchiec | Wittenberg | North Coast (NCAC) | 2008 | Granville | 03/05/05 |
| 4.15 | 13'07.25" | Brian Wanner | College of New Jersey | New Jersey (NJAC) | 2005 | Princeton | 12/05/04 |
| 4.15 | 13'07.25" | Stephen Wendt | SUNY Cortland | SUNYAC | 2006 | Reno | 01/22/05 |
| 4.13 | 13'06.50" | John Brodowski | Muhlenberg | Centennial (CC) | 2005 | Carlisle | 02/27/05 |
| 4.13 | 13'06.50" | Kevin Kirchner | Greenville | independent | Jacksonville | 02/12/05 | |
| 4.13 | 13'06.50" | Tristan Clark | Rose-Hulman | Southern (SCAC) | 2006 | Jacksonville | 02/12/05 |
| 4.12 | 13'06.25" | Adam Powers | Heidelberg | Ohio (OAC) | 2005 | Ada | 02/25/05 |
| 4.12 | 13'06.25" | Jake Van Wagner | Franklin | Heartland (HCAC) | 2007 | Greencastle | 03/04/05 |
| 4.12 | 13'06.25" | Kevin Lehman | Manchester | Heartland (HCAC) | Anderson | 02/26/05 | |
| 4.12 | 13'06.25" | Stephen Feder | Penn State-Erie-Behrend | independent | 2005 | Alliance | 02/26/05 |
| 4.11 | 13'05.75" | Dan Galazeski | College of New Jersey | New Jersey (NJAC) | 2007 | Lawrenceville | 02/06/05 |
| 4.11 | 13'05.75" | Doug Thomasey | Lynchburg | Old Dominion (ODAC) | 2005 | Marietta | 01/22/05 |
| 4.11 | 13'05.75" | Jason Wilson | Christopher Newport | Mason-Dixon | 2008 | Newport News | 12/04/04 |
| 4.11 | 13'05.75" | Jason Yurchak | Elizabethtown | Mid-Atlantic (MAC) | Dickinson | 12/10/04 | |
| 4.11 | 13'05.75" | John Calvo | Susquehanna | Mid-Atlantic (MAC) | 2008 | Selinsgrove | 02/18/05 |
| 4.11 | 13'05.75" | Josh Chartier | MIT | NEWMAC | 2006 | Brunswick | 01/29/05 |
| 4.11 | 13'05.75" | Weston Sale | Ohio Northern | Ohio (OAC) | 2007 | Ada | 01/14/05 |
| 4.10 | 13'05.25" | Brandon Maas | Wisconsin-Platteville | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2008 | Platteville | 03/05/05 |
| 4.10 | 13'05.25" | Brian Lawson | Grinnell | Midwest (MWC) | 2007 | Iowa City | 02/18/05 |
| 4.10 | 13'05.25" | Bryan Gerry | Wisconsin-Eau Claire | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2008 | Stevens Point | 02/26/05 |
| 4.10 | 13'05.25" | Joe Cook | Wisconsin-Stout | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2007 | Platteville | 03/05/05 |
| 4.10 | 13'05.25" | Sean Hogan | Loras | Iowa (IIAC) | 2007 | Decorah | 02/25/05 |
| 4.08 | 13'04.50" | Ben Locke | Augustana (IL) | Illinois & Wisconsin (CCIW) | 2008 | Whitewater | 02/12/05 |
| 4.08 | 13'04.50" | Ben Walker | Hope | Michigan (MIAA) | 2006 | Oshkosh | 02/19/05 |
| 4.08 | 13'04.50" | Dan Majewski | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2007 | Oshkosh | 02/19/05 |
| 4.08 | 13'04.50" | Paul Kelly | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2007 | Oshkosh | 02/19/05 |
| 4.07 | 13'04.25" | Eric Bakkum | Wisconsin-Platteville | Wisconsin (WIAC) | 2007 | Oshkosh | 02/05/05 |
| 4.06 | 13'03.75" | Mike Tornifolio | Ohio Wesleyan | North Coast (NCAC) | 2008 | Granville | 03/05/05 |
| 4.05 | 13'03.50" | Alan Fatzinger | Moravian | Mid-Atlantic (MAC) | Lewisburg | 02/12/05 | |
| 4.05 | 13'03.50" | Doug Fertig | Alfred | New York (NYSCTC) | 2008 | Ithaca | 02/19/05 |
| 4.05 | 13'03.50" | Elliot Matson | SUNY Geneseo | SUNYAC | 2006 | Rochester | 12/11/04 |
| 4.05 | 13'03.50" | Michael Herb | RIT | New York (NYSCTC) | 2007 | Rochester | 12/11/04 |
| 4.05 | 13'03.50" | Nick Honan | Macalester | Minnesota (MIAC) | 2008 | Northfield | 02/25/05 |
| 4.05 | 13'03.50" | Trey Wofford | Emory | University (UAA) | 2005 | New York | 02/25/05 |
| 4.04 | 13'03.00" | Michael Rozelle | McMurry | American Southwest (ASC) | 2008 | Oklahoma City | 02/12/05 |
| 4.04 | 13'03.00" | Scott Langille | Hope | Michigan (MIAA) | 2007 | Chicago | 02/05/05 |
| 4.03 | 13'02.50" | Josh Brown | Central (IA) | Iowa (IIAC) | 2006 | Lincoln | 02/11/05 |
| 4.00 | 13'01.50" | Brian Page | Rose-Hulman | Southern (SCAC) | 2005 | Terre Haute | 02/19/05 |
| 4.00 | 13'01.50" | Dan Golazeski | College of New Jersey | New Jersey (NJAC) | 2007 | Princeton | 12/05/04 |
| 4.00 | 13'01.50" | Josh Kuisle | Buena Vista | Iowa (IIAC) | 2006 | Storm Lake | 02/05/05 |
| 4.00 | 13'01.50" | Phil Brondyke | Hamline | Minnesota (MIAC) | 2007 | Northfield | 02/12/05 |
| 4.00 | 13'01.50" | Thomas Meagher | Kean | New Jersey (NJAC) | Princeton | 01/22/05 | |
| 4.00 | 13'01.50" | Tim Lovett | Wittenberg | North Coast (NCAC) | 2007 | Columbus | 02/19/05 |
| 3.97 | 13'00.25" | Jeff Ossinger | Williams | NESCAC | 2008 | Medford | 02/19/05 |
| 3.97 | 13'00.25" | Levi Diebler | Muskingum | Ohio (OAC) | 2006 | Ada | 02/25/05 |
| 3.97 | 13'00.25" | Matthew Bradley | WPI | NEWMAC | 2008 | Medford | 02/19/05 |
| 3.97 | 13'00.25" | Mike Malone | Ursinus | Centennial (CC) | Carlisle | 02/27/05 | |
| 3.97 | 13'00.25" | Nathaniel Rhodes | Coast Guard Academy | NEWMAC | Medford | 02/19/05 | |
| 3.97 | 13'00.25" | Omari Stephens | MIT | NEWMAC | Medford | 02/19/05 | |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Alex Albers | St. Norbert | Midwest (MWC) | Jacksonville | 03/05/05 | |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Benjamin Wetstone | Hamilton | NESCAC | 2005 | Rochester | 02/26/05 |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | David Senft | Williams | NESCAC | 2007 | Cambridge | 01/22/05 |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Ethan Senecal | SUNY Brockport | New York (NYSCTC) | 2008 | Geneva | 02/19/05 |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Jason Mackie | Richard Stockton | New Jersey (NJAC) | 2006 | Bethlehem | 01/29/05 |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Jordan Knight | Emory | University (UAA) | Newport News | 02/12/05 | |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Josh Kuster | Susquehanna | Mid-Atlantic (MAC) | Selinsgrove | 02/18/05 | |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Josh Quisle | Buena Vista | Iowa (IIAC) | Wayne | 02/12/05 | |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Kevin Klick | Widener | Mid-Atlantic (MAC) | Haverford | 01/30/05 | |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Kyle Judkins | Wheaton (MA) | NEWMAC | 2008 | Providence | 12/15/04 |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Luke Ross | Eastern Mennonite | Old Dominion (ODAC) | 2006 | Dickinson | 12/10/04 |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Luke Sundermeier | Heidelberg | Ohio (OAC) | Ada | 02/11/05 | |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Rob Poiesz | Messiah | Mid-Atlantic (MAC) | 2005 | Dickinson | 12/10/04 |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Robert Hill | Trinity (CT) | NESCAC | 2007 | Middleton | 01/29/05 |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Samuel Winn | SUNY Oswego | SUNYAC/New York (NYSCTC) | Geneva | 02/19/05 | |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Scott Schmidt | Grinnell | Midwest (MWC) | 2007 | Jacksonville | 03/05/05 |
| 3.96 | 12'11.75" | Thomas Simmons | Wheaton (MA) | NEWMAC | 2007 | Providence | 12/22/04 |